Winters in Maryland are full of cold weather, snow, ice, rain, and fluctuations in temperature. We see how these weather conditions can lead to openings in the siding, damage to the siding finish, and moisture penetrating into the underlying walls.

When Topper helps homeowners replace their siding, three choices usually come up: James Hardie fiber cement, LP SmartSide engineered wood, and Mastic vinyl. Below is what you need to know about each material.

1. James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding

Moisture resistance: Fiber cement is resistant to rot and damage from moisture, although it is not waterproof. Water may penetrate where the siding finish is damaged, joints are open, or the flashings are inadequate.

Freeze-thaw performance: The James Hardie HZ5 range is made for areas with freezing conditions, temperature fluctuations, snow, and ice. Its climate-engineered siding is designed to take into account the specific climate; thus, it is a relevant siding option for Maryland residents.

Maintenance: Check for cracks, peeling paint, and degrading caulking. Painting will be needed at some point, depending on the type of product and finish.

Cost: Generally the most expensive of these three options upfront.

Best for: Homeowners looking for longevity and a classic aesthetic, willing to spend more money. We install James Hardie siding for homeowners considering fiber cement.

2. LP SmartSide Engineered Wood Siding

Moisture resistance: LP SmartSide siding features treated wood fibers and its patented SmartGuard process to resist fungi and insects. But if improperly installed or not maintained well, excessive moisture can damage the material. Cut edges require sealing, as per the manufacturer’s recommendations.

Freeze-thaw performance: If LP SmartSide is installed right, it can withstand seasonal changes. To achieve that, it’s crucial to protect the edges, take care of the finish and prevent moisture buildup at joints.

Maintenance: Check for paint peeling, open joints, and exposed edges; repainting and sealing might be necessary.

Cost: Often falls between standard vinyl and fiber cement, depending on the product and installation.

Best for: Those who are interested in a wood-grained siding with the benefits of engineering and moderate cost. We also offer LP SmartSide siding as an alternative to fiber cement and vinyl.

3. Mastic Vinyl Siding

Moisture resistance: Vinyl does not absorb moisture as wood-based sidings do, thus it will not rot; however, there is always a possibility that water gets behind the paneling, and this should be taken into account.

Freeze-thaw performance: Vinyl is able to resist normal winter weather conditions, but in extremely cold conditions, it can become more brittle and susceptible to cracking under impact. Moreover, it expands and contracts depending on the temperature, so proper installation is crucial.

Maintenance: Vinyl is the easiest material to maintain; however, despite the fact that vinyl does not require painting, regular cleaning and inspection for cracks and loose panels are still required.

Cost: Standard vinyl is generally the least expensive option upfront, although premium and insulated products cost more.

Best for: Homeowners who seek affordable, easy-to-maintain siding materials in different styles. We install Mastic vinyl siding for homeowners who prefer this option.

What Matters Most During a Maryland Winter?

There is no such thing as an entirely winter-proof siding material because freeze and thaw conditions will cause existing cracks to widen, while rain and melting snow will create problems for your siding if there is any water behind it that doesn’t drain correctly.

Proper installation of water-resistant barriers, appropriate flashing around doors and windows, and approved installation processes by the manufacturer will help to keep the wall behind it protected. Other considerations include durability, appearance, and maintenance, which are important factors when comparing common types of home siding.

What Should You Budget for New Siding?

Typically, standard vinyl is the most affordable option to start, followed by LP SmartSide, and fiber cement is usually the most expensive. The cost of installation is dependent upon the size of your home, materials selected, labor, removal of the old siding, and any needed repairs underneath.

When comparing bids, remember that they should include the same services, such as trim and removal. Material selection also involves weighing siding costs, durability, and maintenance requirements, rather than looking at the initial price alone.

Which Siding Is Right for Your Home?

James Hardie Fiber Cement may be worth your consideration due to its strength and good performance in cold conditions. The LP SmartSide is wood-looking but is made in a way that guarantees safety and durability, and the Mastic Vinyl siding has a good balance of cost-effectiveness and low maintenance.

Since 1988, our team at Topper Roofing has provided services for siding repairs and replacements in Maryland and other neighboring regions. We can help you understand the strengths of each material and make the decision on what will suit your house best.

Contact us to discuss your siding project and request an estimate.